Price: (2/5) – At $6.25 for a small, Starbucks is the most expensive option on this list. While it’s not the most affordable, the quality, taste, and accessibility make it worth considering for those willing to pay a little extra for the signature PSL experience.
Presentation: (4/5) – The Starbucks PSL presents a beautiful light brown coffee base, topped with whipped cream and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar. While it ranks second in presentation, the whipped cream was a letdown—not even filling half of the dome cap, it gives the drink a sloppy appearance. However, the effort is appreciated, with the hope that on a good day, the whipped cream would be generously filled to the top, completing the classic PSL look.
Taste/Texture: (4.5/5) – The flavor perfectly captures fall in a cup, with a smooth consistency that balanced pumpkin and spice nicely. The taste remained consistent from start to finish, and the milk-to-coffee ratio was ideal, enhancing the creaminess without overpowering the pumpkin.
Pumpkin Vibe: (3.5/5) – The pumpkin vibe score is somewhat low, but that’s based solely on the pumpkin flavor. For those seeking a coffee dominated by pumpkin taste, this option may not be ideal. However, the balance with the spice compliments the coffee nicely and works well for a PSL.
